It was just a photo of a smiling girl in jeans and a vest top, the kind of outfit any young woman might wear in any country. But for Maniza*, a teenager from a conservative town in Pakistan who never leaves the house without her hijab, the selfie she took at home put her at very real risk of an “honour” killing.
“My family are really strict and I always wore a hijab. My father didn’t want me to stay in school but my mum pushed him. He said if I got into trouble, he would kill me. It wasn’t just words, he meant it,” she says.
“I liked my friend’s brother. He said I’m pretty and wanted to marry me. We were joking around and I told him my hair was down to my waist. He said he didn’t believe me and asked for a picture and promised he’d delete it.
“He started getting pushy about meeting up. He threatened to send the photo to my family. He said if I let him touch me he will delete the picture.
“He made a fake account with my picture saying ‘love of my life’. When I reported it [to the social media platform], they said it didn’t break any rules. They didn’t understand my family would kill me if they saw it.”
The issue of intimate image abuse is a global one – yet what can be experienced as an intimate image is often still seen through a western lens. In cultures where family honour focuses on a woman’s perceived chastity, what looks like a harmless photo to an algorithm can often be weaponised in the wrong hands.
A growing number of organisations feel that the debate around intimate image abuse excludes the needs of women in the global south and their cultural context.
“There’s a gap in what platforms define as harmful and what women experience as harmful,” says Hera Hussain, chief executive of Chayn, a charity tackling gender-based violence that has released a report, Explicit Harms of Non-Explicit Images, which urges social media platforms to focus on consent over content.
“Automated content moderation systems are trained to spot nudity, which is an important aspect of tackling image-based abuse, but misses that images can be deadly without nudity,” she says.
In one case, Hussain says, Zarghuna, a 15-year-old from Balochistan, described how a male student took a photo of her wading in a lake during a school picnic. He later projected the image on to a large screen at a school event, which she described as “humiliating”.
“My wet clothes were clinging to my body. Even if you’re wearing a burqa, if it outlines your body, people will say you are making an exhibition,” said Zarghuna.
“Sometimes images are taken of my friends in our classroom and a WhatsApp comes asking for sexual favours, saying: ‘I have your image, I can make it public.’
“These cases are where the woman is not actually nude. It’s a simple image but it is harmful because you don’t know what the person who has it will do with it. They can get money, sexual favours or unwanted relationships from the fear of it.”
The gender divide online is stark in Pakistan. Two-thirds of Instagram users are male, and of the 100 million TikTok users, more than 70% are also estimated to be male.
Last year, 14-year-old Hira Anwar was lured to Pakistan from the US and killed by her father over her TikTok videos. Another teenage TikTok user, Sana Yousaf, was murdered last year by a man who had become obsessed with her online account.
“[These images] can trigger violence and close doors for women. They have been taken out of education and jobs, pressured or forced into marriage, [subjected to] verbal and physical assault and divorce, as well as in extreme cases, suicide, murder and femicide,” Hussain says.
For Maniza, the photo changed her life. “My mother heard and knew my father would kill us both, so she made me leave school. I have to get married as soon as a proposal is found. Every day I am living in fear. That picture is still out there and there’s nothing I can do.”
A helpline run by Pakistan’s Digital Rights Foundation (DRF) receives approximately 250 complaints a month. In one recent case, it was able to remove AI-generated videos of a teacher kissing a man on Instagram.
“The consequences can be devastating, particularly in contexts like Pakistan where women’s sexuality, or even simply their presence online, is heavily policed and intimate imagery carries enormous social stigma,” says Nighat Dad, a lawyer who founded the DRF.
“Platform policies are often designed without sufficient understanding of cultural contexts and the ways gendered harm manifests differently across communities.
“We repeatedly see cases where something may not fit a platform’s narrow definition of intimate or sexual content, but in the survivor’s context it is clearly being used to sexualise, shame or endanger her,” Dad says.
Chayn is calling for tech companies to bring cultural context into moderation and introduce a consent-based reporting pathway.
Hussain says: “Otherwise it’s like someone throwing a bomb and focusing on what type of bomb it is instead of the damage it can do.”
Meta did not respond to a request for comment on this article.
* Name has been changed