Early evening summary
Andy Burnham has said he saw “some grounds for optimism” at a meeting of the Coalition of the Willing in Berlin because he felt there was consensus that “there is no decision about Ukraine without Ukraine in the room and no decision about European security without Europe represented in the room.” There is more on this on our Europe live blog.
For a full list of all the stories covered on the blog today, do scroll through the list of key event headlines near the top of the blog.
Final questions, on far-right in Europe, Boris Johnson, Reform UK in the Senedd, the EU-UK reset deal, and Guardian comments
Before I wrap up, I will try some quickfire responses.
sickofgove asks:
I have a question Andrew: Do you think that our leaving the EU has enabled the far right parties in Europe to gain a bigger stronghold than if we had remained. I personally feel that we were something of a stabilising influence despite our moaning on about everything. I would be interested in what you and your colleagues think.
I don’t think Brexit had an impact on the rise of far-right parties in the EU countries – other than to discourage some of them, which had been toying with the idea of backing withdrawal from the EU, to give up on the idea because it ended so badly for the UK.
But it did shift the balance of power in the European Council a bit away from the northern, fiscal discipline bloc.
WalkthiswayX asks:
Dear Andrew, is it true Boris is going to make a comeback?
I don’t think that is likely any time soon. There is no opening for him either in the Conservative party, or in Reform UK. But he is only in his early 60s. It is not impossible that, at some point in the next 10 years, some cause crops up that he can make his own, and voters give him another chance because they have forgotten about partygate.
Mousebirdbadger asks:
Hello again. My question - if the official opposition (Reform) is boycotting the Senedd/ Welsh assembly and going to the pub instead, can they as individual MSs be recalled for dereliction of duty, or some such charge?
I don’t know enough about the Senedd rules to give you an answer on this. I did ask a colleague who covers Wales, who told me: “Possibly? But it hasn’t been mooted so far - it’s all untested waters.”
But to take action against the entire Reform UK group in the Senedd would look like victimising the party, and would send a terrible signal to the 29% of Welsh voters who supported them in the elections.
Flipchart45 asks:
Question for Andrew: Will Andy Burnham’s new EU deal improve or worsen Labour’s polling ratings and therefore their electoral chances?
Andy Burnham thinks it will be popular, and polling seems to confirm this.
Dougal asks:
How are you bearing up with the absence of a daily comments thread, Andrew? Did your plea for readers to get in touch / engage via other channels have much effect?
I miss the comments. Some people get in touch using the politics.live@theguardian.com email, but not many. It would be nice to get more emails. You can also find me on Bluesky.
Updated
Q&A: Can politicians still deliver great speeches?
NoMoreMrNice asks:
Hi Andrew - nice to have you back. Or us back, I guess. Thanks for the blog.
As someone who must follow the daily political shenanigans more than most, do you find the way it functions depressing? Less the positions or the policies, but the mechanisms of it - in particular the regular pretence that anybody from another party is absolutely wrong; that anything you disagree with is a laughable disgrace; that politicians who know very well how difficult the problems are pretend it’s just government incompetence that means they aren’t solved; and the general poverty of discourse.
I’ve been re-reading some of the speeches from around the abolition of slavery, and I just can’t imagine any modern politician reaching the same level of rhetoric, or of nuance, now. Even 20 years ago, I remember some politicians who gave cracking speeches in parliament, raising really interesting perspectives. Tony Benn was a great speaker, but I always liked Tony Wright too. Do MPs still give interesting speeches, and I just don’t see them? Or is it just me growing grumpy grumpier with age, and harking back to some prelapsarian idyll that never really existed?
If not, and you think there is an issue with the *how* of modern politics, do you see any particular causes, or any possible solutions? To me, we seem to have more public debate than ever, and nearly all of it seems almost entirely banal and pointless.
Until now, I have been choosing questions where I felt reasonably well qualified to give an answer. I posted this one because it is interesting and challenging; I’m not sure I do have an answer, but here goes anyway.
Years ago I wrote a book that involved reading 19th century debates and, I agree, they require a level of concentration that would be beyond most parliamentarians, or listeners, now. But that parliamentary debate was an elite activity, it was a pre-democratic age, and there was no TV.
Even 30 years ago, the speech was a key communication device in British politics. People like Gordon Brown regarded a good speech as the way you shifted public opinion. I don’t think there are many political leaders who think quite like that now; they still deliver speeches, but soundbites, interviews, social media clips, tweets and TikToks are often their preferred ways of getting the message across.
(There are exceptions; Alan Milburn grew up in the ‘speeches matter’ school of politics, and the speech he gave launching his report this week was powerful stuff.)
That does not mean today’s politicians are less intelligent; I think it’s about attention spans being shorter, and people being exposed to multiple sources of information at the same time. Wilberforce would have been rubbish on Twitter.
Does it mean public debate is more banal and pointless? I fear it does, though Substack and podcasts show that there are still plenty of people in politics who know how to articulate an argument at length.
Q&A: What is happening on PR and Lords reform?
Here are two questions on constitutional reform.
MEGAHEAD1 asks:
AS - what is the mood music in the halls of govt about PR? Does PLP/Gov really want to change our political voting system and does it need to be a referendum or could it go into a manifesto but with added risk?
And inote asks:
Question Andrew: What is happening with the Labour manifesto commitment to hold public consultation on proposals to replace the House of Lords with an alternative second chamber more representative of the UK’s nations and regions?
At the moment, almost nothing is happening on electoral reform or Lords reform.
In his Labour conference speech, Andy Burnham said he would set up a national commission on electoral reform. He is probably more committed to PR than any previous Labour PM, even Tony Blair. But, since conference, we have heard zilch about this.
My understanding is that No 10 was determined to show it was focused on the cost of living in the first 100 days, and opening a debate on PR was viewed as a distraction. With Europe, social care reform, and the Milburn report also taking up a lot of time, Burnham may feel he does not have the bandwidth for this. As Rob Ford explained on Bluesky recently, the Green party’s “Zionism is racism” motion did not help the PR cause in Labour circles either.
On Lords reform, there is also radio silence.
But they might be connected. In his conference speech, Burnham did not commit to including PR in the Labour manifesto. He said they would fight the next election “with a manifesto commitment to change the electoral system so that everyone’s vote counts and everyone’s voice is heard”. I don’t know what he had in mind when he drafted those words, but you could propose some form of elected element for the Lords which would be consistent with making sure “everyone’s voice is heard” but which would not be PR for the Commons. At a pinch, I suppose you could argue the supplementary vote for mayoral elections would meet this pledge, provided enough people had a mayor to vote for.
Q&A: How can Burnham justify wanting a rerun of the Brexit referendum, but not allowing a rerun of the Scottish independence one?
WolfFlow asks:
Andrew: How can Burnham say “no discussion on constitutional issues” in relation to Scotland yet take entirely the opposite view wrt the EU?
At what point will the media notice the hypocrisy?
We have noticed, and you are right to say these two positions are inconsistent. But there is an important difference. Andy Burnham wants to overturn the 2016 Brexit vote; he doesn’t want to overturn the 2014 IndyRef.
It is not unreasonable for a PM to refuse to do something if he regards it as a bad idea.
At some point, that position would be impossible to sustain if the Scottish people made it clear that they did want independence. We may get to that point in the end. But, with the independence polling still roughly in 50/50 territory, I think Burnham will be able to hold off on granting a referendum for some time.
Updated
Q&A: Why did Burnham keep Shabana Mahmood as home secretary?
rolandb asks:
Andrew: why do you think Burnham kept Mahmood as Home Secretary and what are his options for getting rid of her now, given that she seems to have her own agenda which is inimical to the progressive alliance Burnham appears to want?
We think that Andy Burnham was minded to make Shabana Mahmood chancellor at one point and then lost his nerve – perhaps because he thought she would be too independent-minded, and because he thought John Healey would be more amenable.
You might be assuming that Andy Burnham is more liberal than he actually is. Remember, one of his chief mentors in politics was David Blunkett. His career flourished under Tony Blair. And this is what Burnham told Pippa Crerar in an interview during the Makerfield byelection campaign, when she asked about Reform UK claims he was pro-immigration. He said:
I’m not like that. You know me. I was in the Home Office under Tony Blair, and actually, it was my job to return people. That was my specific role.
I used to have to travel to governments around the world and persuade them to take back planes of people who had come here with no basis to stay, so you know, I never have been shy of getting to grips with these difficult issues.
Burnham forced Mahmood to water down her indefinite leave to remain plans. But I don’t think he wants an ultra-liberal home secretary, having her there has not so far stopped him winning back Green and Lib Dem voters, and I assume he thinks she is doing a decent job reducing the salience of immigration as an issue.
Q&A: Has James Cleverly got any chance of being elected London mayor?
Wiven2 asks:
Andrew, has James Cleverly got any hope in becoming London’s mayor? At the moment it’s a toss up between none and Bob I think.
According to these odds, James Cleverly is at 6/1 – with Sadiq Khan the firm favourite. That looks about right. (They also have Laila Cunningham, the Reform UK candidate, at 3/1, which seems to rate her chances of winning far too high.) Cleverly may look like a no hope candidate now but, as Peter Walker pointed out earlier (see 10.58am), he is a much stronger candidate than any of the last three Tories to stand. Khan has never been an outstanding campaigner and, if he does not run again, the Labour figures being talked about as potential alternatives don’t sound impressive either. And Cleverly has a year and a half to carve out a distinct, liberal, London-friendly version of Conservatism that could work in 2028. It would mean distancing himself from Kemi Badenoch and the national party. But Tory high command would allow that, as they did with Boris Johnson when he won in 2008.
Q&A: Why is Badenoch getting more popular, and will she still be Tory leader at next election?
Here are two questions about Kemi Badenoch.
oidptg1 asks:
Question for Andrew: I look at Badenoch and I listen to her interviews and I find her spectacularly abrasive and underprepared to answer detailed questions.
That’s obviously a value-judgement on my part, but on major policy issues such as the UK involvement in the Iran War, Israel/Gaza, US-UK relations in the context of Madelson and Chagos she seems to make the opportunistic-but-wrong call.
That said, her approval ratings are growing and people seem to really like her.
I’d be interested to hear your reflections on what you think people are responding to so positively about her policies and her approach.
Is it simply that it makes a good insta clip?
3chordgenius asks:
Andrew, do you think Kemi Badenoch will last till the election as leader of the opposition? And dare I ask, who are the possible replacements.
Kemi Badenoch’s approval ratings are going up. But that is not because she is getting more popular with people like oidptg1 (ie, Guardian reading types).
Peter Kellner, the former YouGov president, wrote a good article on his Substack blog over the summer explaining what is going on. He says her ratings have shot up because she has won over voters on the right. Here is an excerpt.
Last October, Conservative voters were even more likely than the wider public to say Badenoch did NOT look like a prime minister in waiting. Her figures are now very different. The percentage of Tory voters who say she DOES look like a PM in waiting has jumped from 17 to 62, while the percentage who disagree has slumped from 67 to 25.
In half a century of monitoring poll findings, I cannot recall a leader’s appeal to their own party’s voters rising so dramatically. Badenoch has transformed her credibility among those who voted Tory in 2024 but were disillusioned by her performance in her first year as party leader. She has won the first round in her battle to revive her party’s fortunes and see off Farage.
And here are two charts illustrating this point.
Badenoch is “spectacularly abrasive”. But she is abrasive towards leftwingers, and so right-leaning voters seem to like that.
As to whether she will stay until the next election, yes, almost certainly. There is no desire at all in the party (MPs, peers, members, donors or the Tory press) to get rid of her. There are no rivals trying to get rid of her. And it is not even obvious that anyone else could do a better job, given that the policy decisions that might make the Tories more electable are unacceptable to the party at large.
Q&A: What will happen with the Farage inquiry, and will he stay on as Reform UK leader?
And here are two questions about Nigel Farage.
RustyArms asks:
Andrew - given Nigel’s net favourability is under water and RefUK Ltd continue to slide in the polls, do you think Nigel has had enough and might step aside, and if so how do you think the future plays out for them?
Fisherbloke47 asks:
Hi Andrew, What’s the latest on the Farage donations scandal? It appears to be dragging on. And do you think Farage will fight on if found guilty and recalled? I note Farage is on record stating he expects an adverse result citing the usual “Establishment Plot” nonsense.
Reform UK has had a bad year but – unless there is something serious happening in his private life, or with his health, that we don’t know about – I find it very, very, very hard to imagine Nigel Farage stepping away before the election. This is a guy who devoted himself to a cause (leaving the EU) that for at least 15 years was a complete no-hope enterprise. He likes campaigning, he is good at it, and he still has an outside chance of being PM. Why would he give it up?
Re the donations scandal, we think the parliamentary commissioner for standards has written his report and it is now with the standards committee. They can spend months dealing with these matters. I would be amazed if the commissioner has not concluded that Farage broke the rules by not declaring the £5m Harborne donations; the rules are clear that, if there could be a perception of a donation being linked to parliamentary activity, it should be declared. But I think it is possible the committee could find a way of not recommending a long suspension. That would be quite a perverse finding; but its conclusions in the James McMurdock case were almost unbelievably lenient.
If they do recommend a suspension of 10 days or more, I think there will be a recall byelection, and Farage will win again, quite easily.
Q&A: Where is Andy Burnham's desire for a closer relationship with the EU going to end up?
Here are two related questions on Andy Burnham’s desire for a closer relationship with the EU.
KingInYellow asks:
WRT the article and topic of the EU indicating it won’t discuss long term permanent close relations until it is assured Burnham is serious, do you think this will mean Burnham is treading water on this subject until after a GE has been fought with the specific issue of a much closer relationship with the EU in (or out) of party manifestos in the UK?
And DownsideUp asks:
Hi Andrew. Do you think that the pro-EU campaign is being complacent in not having a co-ordinated campaign in place?
It seems that the “Stay Out” campaign group is setting the terms of the debate. For example, I already know that slogan but I don’t even know if their opponents are Remainers/Rejoiners/Joiners.
I have even less idea what a new EU relationship would look like. It feels a reset has been launched on a whim.
I think there is going to be a lot of treading water on this for some time. I don’t think anyone can predict the outcome of this process with any confidence at all until we know the results of the next election.
Andy Burnham is on record as saying that he would like to rejoin, and I think he is sincere in wanting to achieve a radical shift. But he has also – right from the moment he opened this debate in his conference speech – stressed his desire to find a consensus. I think there will come a point, at some point in the future, when there is a strong consensus (say, 70/30) in favour of rejoining. But I think that could take a decade, at least, and it would probably require the Tories to have a leader willing to disown the Brexit cult and say it has been a mistake. Before that, there might be a firm consensus sooner behind some sort of Swiss option.
Re the second question, it would be hard for the pro-EU side to have a campaign in place when they don’t know where they are heading. But I think No 10 have been a bit alarmed about quite how quickly and forcefully the Stay Out campaign has launched. Stay Out are trying to shape the terms of the debate. Years ago Dominic Cummings led a campaign against joining the euro. Tony Blair never opted for this in the end and Cummings argued afterwards (rightly) that just ensuring the referendum never happened in the first place was a strategic victory for his side.
Burnham gets criticised for launching this debate without seeming to know where he wants it to end up. Personally, I don’t think that’s necessarily a bad thing. He’s testing public opinion, and seeing where it will go. We may be surprised. I’ve been struck by how, even though Stay Out have marshalled some strong arguments against rejoining, no one is seriously contesting Burnham’s claim that Brexit has done more harm than good. Stay Out are making other arguments. On the key point of contention, Burnham seems to have won already.
From now on, I will be focusing on the Q&A.
To follow what is happening at the Coalition of the Willing summit, do read Jakub Krupa’s Europe live blog.
Q&A: When will the next election happen?
ibatch40 asks:
@Andrew - gov must call a GE by August 2029. Burnham has ruled out a 2027 GE, so do you think that means we’ll have one in 2028? Because it’s inconceivable they’d wait till 2029 when gov has to cut spending isn’t it?
The conventional wisdom in British politics is that prime ministers call elections on the first Thursday after they have been in office for four years and when polling suggests they will win. Often this ends up as the first Thursday in May, when local elections happen anyway.
That is because a PM with a decent chance of winning at that point normally does not want to risk ‘events’ taking away his or her lead, and leaving no room for manoeuvre, as the five-year hard deadline looms.
On that basis, 2028 would be a reasonable guess.
You are right to say Burnham has ruled out an election in 2027. Theresa May also ruled out an election in 2017 – until she changed her mind. It is not impossible that Burnham might do this. But voters don’t like early elections, and dozens of Labour MPs would probably lose their seats, and so I can only see that happening unless Burnham can come up with a very, very good pretext to justify one. I think that’s unlikely. (And I hope it won’t happen too – I’ve booked a holiday for next spring.)
Updated
As Jennifer Rankin reports, one of the issues still being haggled over at the last minute ahead of tomorrow’s UK-EU reset deal has been how many young EU nationals would be allowed to come to Britain under the youth mobility scheme.
In a report for the i, Arj Singh says the EU seems to have won this one. He says:
The UK and EU have provisionally agreed there will be a cap of 100,000 visas on a landmark Brexit reset deal to allow easier travel, work and study for under-32s between the two areas, The i Paper has learnt …
It means 100,000 Brits stand to benefit from easier arrangements to travel, work and study in the EU from as early as 2028, with a final deadline of 2030, and vice versa.
The i Paper has also learnt the UK and EU have agreed the scheme will be open to those aged 18 to 31 on the first day of their intended stay on the other side, despite initial suggestions it would only be open to under-30s.
Singh says this still needs to be signed off by EU member states. He adds:
The final 100,000 represents a late compromise from the UK, which had been pushing for 80,000, but British negotiators are likely to regard it as a fair one given the EU’s initial push for an uncapped scheme.
No 10 says UK and Norway jointly spending £100m on two advanced fast attack boats for Ukraine
In addition to 1,000 long-range strike drones (see 12.03pm), Downing Street has also announced that the UK is buying two advanced fast attack boats for Ukraine. The UK and Norway are jointly paying the £100m cost, and they will be made in Britain, No 10 said.
Andy Burnham said:
Funded with Norway, built here at home in the UK, and delivering game-changing capability to the Ukrainians, this project will not just strengthen Black Sea defences, but supports European security too.
Stable and secure sea lanes are arteries of global trade, and Russia’s ongoing indiscriminate attacks in the Black Sea are not just hurting Ukraine and our European Allies but also hitting the world’s most vulnerable.
Government to appoint men's health ambassador for England
It is international men’s day and, to mark that, the Department of Health and Social Care has announced that it is looking for someone to appoint as “England’s first men’s health ambassador, to help men live longer, healthier and happier lives”. In a news release, it says:
The ambassador will be a national voice for men’s physical and mental health, championing services that make it easier for men to get help close to home, at work and in their communities.
No 10 says talks on UK-EU reset deal due to be announced tomorrow 'going down to wire'
Downing Street has said the talks about the UK-EU reset deal due to be announced at a summit tomorrow are “going down to the wire”.
At the No 10 lobby briefing, the PM’s press secretary said:
The talks with the EU are going down to the wire.
If we secure a deal at tomorrow’s summit, the government will bring forward legislation to parliament next week.
There is a consensus in the country that change needs to happen.
The choice over the coming days is clear: stand with Boris Johnson and Kemi Badenoch defending a broken status quo, or with Andy Burnham delivering change, cutting costs for business, helping with the costs of the weekly shop and creating opportunities for young people.
In an article for the Daily Mail today, Kemi Badenoch claimed the deal being unveiled tomorrow would take the UK backwards. She said:
The three central purposes of Brexit were control over our money, over our laws and over our borders. On each of those, Burnham is moving us backwards.
Consider his proposed agreement on food and agricultural products. The farmers and businesses exporting to the EU will welcome fewer checks and less paperwork.
But what about the 90 per cent of businesses and farmers who don’t export to Europe? They are going to be forced backwards on innovations like precision breeding and GM crops, on which Britain has been able to surge ahead of the EU since leaving.
But, at the lobby briefing, the PM’s press secretary defended the decision to seek a reset. He said:
The status quo is not working. Brexit has done more harm than good.
It has not fixed what was broken a decade ago and those problems have become even more severe.
The cost of living has risen, it’s harder for British people to travel and businesses to trade, and the small boats crisis has reached our shores.
We ended up with a harder Brexit than was promised at the referendum. The hard Brexit that was negotiated has impacted people’s everyday lives, longer queues at the airport and young people missing out on the chance to live, work or study abroad.
The world has changed. Russia poses a much more direct threat to European security, tariffs have disrupted trade and the war in Iran has hit people’s pockets.
Here is Jennifer Rankin’s guide to what is expected to be announced tomorrow.
Lack of early border controls made UK ‘extremely vulnerable’ to Covid, inquiry finds
The lack of international border controls at the start of the pandemic left the UK in an “extremely vulnerable position”, the Covid inquiry has concluded. Jessica Murray has the story.
Jenrick widely mocked after criticising 'deep scar' left by Thatcher's policies - despite naming his daughter after her
Robert Jenrick has been mocked and criticised after giving an interview critical of Margaret Thatcher.
At the Conservative party conference just two years ago, before he defected to Reform UK, Jenrick astonished party members by revealing that, such was his admiration for the former PM, he had burdened one of his daughters with Thatcher as a middle name.
Even by Tory standards that was seen as excessive – although Thatcher is probably the only former party leader, other than Winston Churchill, who has always been venerated by the vast majority of its members.
Nigel Farage, the Reform UK leader, was also a huge Thatcher admirer in the 1980s, and he only left the Conservative party after she was ousted and John Major signed the Maastricht Treaty.
But Reform UK are now polling well in former Labour seats in the Midlands and the north of England and Jenrick’s comments about Thatcher seem to be part of a deliberate tilt to appeal to this audience.
In an interview with the Sun, Jenrick said:
I grew up in the Black Country, and my mum and dad worked in heavy industry and those industries were destroyed in the 1970s by out-of-control trade unions, bad management, and by the policies that Labour and Tory governments pursued at that time.
And yeah, the Thatcher government turned that around. But they also did it in a way which left a deep scar on these communities.
Businesses went under. There was a loss of pride and identity which has taken a long time and perhaps has never fully recovered.
Jenrick also criticised Kemi Badenoch, the Conservative leader, for “wrapping herself in the mantle of Margaret Thatcher”. Pointing out that Burnham also defines himself in relation to Thatcher (the PM argues that many of the problems facing Britain now started with policies she introduced), Jenrick said Westminster should “move on” and talk about the future. He said:
Margaret Thatcher is as dated a reference to my kids as Winston Churchill was to me when I was growing up, and that doesn’t feel that long ago.
In a post on social media, Luke Tryl, the More in Common pollster, said that disowning Thatcherism was a logical electoral strategy for Reform UK.
Further evidence I think Reform is leaning into where their actual potential voter pool actually is and if you’re not going to be able to squeeze affluent Tories, your voter pool of socially conservative/economically statist voters dont want Thatcherism 2.0
But Jenrick has also been widely mocked for his comments, which will do nothing to quell claims that – even by MP standards – he is a shameless opportunist.
Quite what Jenrick’s daughter thinks of this all remains a mystery. However, the Tories have issued a comment. A Conservative spokesperson said:
Whether it’s Brexit, the border or the Iron Lady, Robert Jenrick’s political compass is all over the place. Having named his daughter after Margaret Thatcher, Bobbie now wants to disown her.
You cannot believe a word he says. He has no fixed principles, no convictions and no consistency. He is a political weather vane, pointing whichever way he thinks the wind is blowing.
It is impossible to keep up with which version of Robert Jenrick will turn up next.
Updated
UK to give Ukraine 1,000 long-range strike drones
Andy Burnham is going to announce details of a £260m package of support for Ukraine at the Coalition of the Willing meeting in Berlin this afternoon. It will include more than 1,000 long-range strike drones. No 10 says:
Arriving in Berlin today, Andy Burnham is set to announce a new £260m package, including long-range drones, which can travel more than 1000km - the equivalent to the distance between London and Berlin.
The package will include strike drones able to carry heavy warheads capable of flattening targets in a single hit, enabling Ukraine to target military production facilities and other legitimate military targets far behind the front lines.
The UK will also build and deliver vital maritime, logistical, and surveillance drones to allow Ukraine to resupply front line forces, ensuring stocks such as blood and fridges for medical stores reach those on the front line …
Today’s announcement of further support won’t just boost Ukraine’s front lines; it will also bring jobs and opportunity around the country, with more than 80% of this funding to be spent in the UK – including with small and medium-sized businesses across Wales, Northern Ireland, and Scotland.
Leaseholders in England and Wales to have ground rent capped in 2028
Matthew Pennycook, the housing minister, was doing an interview round this morning to promote the news that the government is publishing its leasehold reform bill today. Under the plans, leaseholders in England and Wales will have their ground rent capped in 2028. Kiran Stacey has the details.
Labour has issued this statement about James Cleverly being selected as the Tory candidate for London mayor. It is from Bridget Phillipson, the Labour chair.
James Cleverly has a record of failure and now wants to inflict his disastrous CV on London.
He backed a no deal Brexit and Liz Truss’s disastrous mini-budget, voted for cuts to policing and youth services, and opposed action to clean up London’s air.
Londoners should never forgive and never forget the damage the Conservatives did to our capital. They deserve a better future, not a return to the same old Tory failure.
UK must decide whether it wants to be or not to be in EU, says Rosencrantz at EU summit
Jakub Krupa writes the Guardian’s Europe live blog.
Over in Brussels, EU ministers are arriving for foreign affairs talks, with questions already popping up about tomorrow’s EU-UK summit, 10 years on from Britain’s vote to leave the bloc.
Ireland’s EU minister Thomas Byrne said the main areas to be discussed on Friday “will have very significant benefits” for all parties, with the sanitary and phytosanitary agreement set to resolve “one of the biggest problems out of Brexit”.
But he was cautious talking about the future relationship with the EU, saying that while he had “no doubt that the EU and Britain will want to go further on that path, we have seen how complex even dealing with the issues for tomorrow is and how long it takes.”
Sweden’s Jessica Rosencrantz stressed it is “up to the citizens of the UK to decide how close you want to work with the EU”.
But, again, asked if Britain could rejoin the bloc and keep its historical opt-outs and rebates, she dismissed it as “a highly speculative question”. She added:
Let’s remember how the discussion was at the time of Brexit. In that light, I think it is amazing that we now can have a big summit together, with discussions on how we can come closer together when it comes to trade and mobility.
Poland’s EU minister Ignacy Niemczycki said Warsaw’s approach “has always been very pragmatic,” as he stressed that the EU after Brexit is “weaker.” He said:
I would like us, wherever possible, to work out such mechanisms so it works for both of us. … This is a country that thinks similarly to us in Europe on many issues and there is no reason for us to treat each other like enemies. We are friends and let’s find the right formula for that.
In a cheeky comment, he added:
I would encourage everyone to think seriously about the benefits of being in the EU, … and I think the people of the UK see it [too], now that they are outside the union.
Cleverly accuses Burnham of being 'anti-London', after being named as Tory candidate for mayor
These are from my colleague Peter Walker, who was at the Tory event where James Cleverly was named as the party’s candidate for London mayor.
Peter posted this before the result was announced.
Khan (who may or may not stand a 4th time) has thus far faced a dilettante who decided to campaign on a racist platform (Zack Goldsmith) and two oddballs in Shaun Bailey and then Susan Hall. Not even he can be lucky yet again
And he posted these later.
Interesting that [the Conservatives] did not say how many votes were cast, just the percentage - which perhaps indicates it was not a huge number
Cleverly’s speech is mainly an attack on Labour and Khan, which is likely to be a theme for his campaign: “Burnham can’t stand London and Khan stand up to Burnham.” Also a pitch about building houses and cutting crime, and boosting transport.
Cleverly says he would “end Khan’s war on motorists”, which is a sign he might lean into the anti-cycling and walking rhetoric which the London Tories have a habit of espousing. Expect talk about LTNs and 20mph zones.
In the media Q&A Cleverly is pinned down on whether he backs the Tory party line on wanting to leave the ECHR and opposes net zero. He confirms he does (as he has to). Such things will be ready ammunition for Labour.
Cleverly says of Andy Burnham, “His residual behaviour is to be anti-London”. This will very much be a theme of his campaign, it seems. Not sure how resonant a “poor London!” message will be even in London
Tories choose James Cleverly as their candidate for London mayor in 2028
James Cleverly has been selected as the Conservative party’s candidate for the next London mayoral election.
The former foreign secretary and former home secretary won 86% of the votes in the ballot, beating Westminster councillor Festus Akinbusoye and former parliamentary candidate Sara Gezdari. A fourth candidate, communications professional Alex Challoner, was eliminated before the shortlist was drawn up for the ballot.
The next election for London mayor will take place in 2028.
Cleverly said he was “all in” for the race and would not be seeking reselection as an MP. He represents Braintree in Essex.
After the result was announced, Cleverly said the current mayor, Labour’s Sadiq Khan, was letting London down. He said:
People are leaving London, or not choosing to come here in the first place, businesses, job creators, families leaving London, and by the time of the election in 2028, Khan will have been mayor for 12 years, and those two things are related.
The problems London faces are the symptoms. Khan is the cause.
When I ask Londoners, do you feel safe walking home at night? The answer is no.
It’s shameful, it’s a failure, and it’s not just crime.
We have had the worst period of housebuilding since the second world war and only the highest-earning Londoners can afford the cheapest houses in London.
Congratulating Cleverly, Kemi Badenoch said London was in decline and Labour was to blame.
Updated
Any questions for Andrew Sparrow?
This afternoon I will be answering questions from readers. Please post your questions below the line (comments are open today), and I will be answering from about 3pm until 5pm, or a bit later.
This is the latest in a regular Conversations series where Guardian journalists answer questions from readers. I last did one in April.
Please feel free to ask about anything related to British politics. I will try to answer as many as I can, but in particular I will focus on a) the ones that seem most interesting and b) the ones where I think I might have something sensible to say.
Updated
Tulip Siddiq says she is considering legal action against former Bangladesh leader
The former minister Tulip Siddiq has said she is considering taking legal action against the former interim leader of Bangladesh over corruption allegations made by his administration led her to resign from the UK government last year, Alexandra Topping reports.
In her Today programme interview, Kemi Badenoch said that she was “worried” by the idea of the government intervening to get the Russell Brand prison message video removed from YouTube. (See 10.04am.) She said that, while Brand had been convicted, his wife (who posted the video) was a separate person.
Badenoch said:
My personal opinion is that Russell Brand has been convicted. He is guilty under the law. The rule of law applies to everyone in this country.
His wife is a separate person. She can make the protestations that she likes. I’m very concerned if people in prison are able to use other conduits to be able to send messages. I think that that is unorthodox.
But YouTube is a private platform. I think that immediately demanding the private platforms take things down without looking at exactly whether a law has been broken is not where I would start from.
If we want to make legislation for that, then we can look at that. But I’m quite worried about government intervening.
During his interview round this morning, Matthew Pennycook said the Ministry of Justice is in “dialogue” with Google as it tries to get the tech firm to take down the Russell Brand video. (See 10.04pm.)
A spokesperson for the Ministry of Justice said:
It is only right that the government asks for content that is distressing for victims to be taken down and we strongly believe YouTube should remove this content.
Removal ultimately depends on the platform’s own terms.
Meta disabled Brand’s Instagram and Facebook accounts after his conviction, the Press Association reports.
A Google spokesperson said:
We’re aware of the new content and our teams are investigating. We suspended Russell Brand’s channel from the YouTube Partner Programme in September 2023. The channel has not been able to monetise on YouTube since then.
Minister admits government cannot force Google to remove Russell Brand prison video from YouTube
The government has no power to make Google take down a YouTube video with a message from Russell Brand from prison claiming he is innocent of his crimes, a minister has admitted.
As Nadeem Badshah reports, the government has asked Google to take down the video.
Google has reportedly denied the request because it determined its rules had not been broken, the Press Association reports.
Asked about this in an interview on BBC Breakfast this morning, Matthew Pennycook, the housing minister, said:
We don’t have any power to mandate a removal of content. That is up to Google. It’s based on their terms and conditions.
But as I’ve been very clear, we’ve made a request in this instance because we feel very strongly that victims shouldn’t have to see this content.
We hope they do so because they have taken action on their platform before. They banned, for example in 2023, Russell Brand for making money off the platform because his off-platform behaviour was seen to cause harm.
BAE to slash 1,000 jobs across head office and air business to streamline orders
BAE Systems has announced plans to cut more than 1,000 jobs from its workforce, triggering calls for ministers to place extra orders with Britain’s biggest defence contractor, Lauren Almeida and Jasper Jolly report.
Badenoch says it's 'disturbing' that Xi, Trump and Putin look like they're 'trying to carve up world between them'
Alexandra Topping is a Guardian political correspondent.
Kemi Badenoch was in a straight-talking mode on the media round this morning, calling the historic meeting between Trump, Xi and Putin “disturbing”, saying it looked like they were trying to “carve” up the world” between them.
Speaking on the Today programme, the leader of the opposition said the meeting was “absolutely not reassuring”.
She said:
There are three world leaders who look like they’re trying to carve up the world between them, a tri-polar world where Xi gets Asia, America gets the western hemisphere and Russia gets Europe, and that is very concerning, especially seeing Donald Trump call President Putin his friend.
Russia is not America’s friend, it certainly hasn’t been during my lifetime. But also at a time when we’re all worried about where the Ukraine war is going, the message that is sending to President Zelensky and of course the other summit that is taking place … is very concerning indeed.
And what I want to know is where we fit in in all of this. I don’t want to be in a polarised world run by Russia. I’ll do everything I can to make sure that doesn’t happen.
Badenoch went further than the prime minister, who was asked about the meeting by Ed Davey at prime minister’s questions yesterday. The Liberal Democrat leader said “the security implications of Trump, Putin and Xi cosying up” should highlight the need for a fresh deal with the European Union.
Burnham replied that he would be in Berlin for a meeting of the Coalition of the Willing to support Ukraine in China, but stopped short of expressing concern about the meeting of the three world leaders.
He said:
The thing that we need to do is continue to stand squarely by Ukraine and that is what this government will do.
And on this issue, I do pay tribute to all sides of the house because that is what we’ve managed to do in the years since the conflict began and that is the right thing to do … Let that clear message go out as that meeting takes place in [China] – this country is squarely with Ukraine.
Badenoch says using amputee athletes to justify cutting disability benefits was ‘message of hope’
Good morning. At PMQs yesterday Andy Burnham said that Kemi Badenoch should withdraw the “double amputees run marathons” comment that she used to justify the Tory plan to cut sickness and disability benefits by £14bn. It was “crass and insensitive”, he said.
This morning Badenoch defended what she was saying claimed that, in fact, she was delivering a “message of hope”.
In an interview on the Today programme, asked if she accepted that her remark was insensitive, Badenoch said she didn’t. She went on:
I will speak the truth and I will say what I believe is common sense. And what I know is that, if people can work, then we should encourage them to work.
And what I’m saying is actually a message of hope, that if people even with significant, problems can work, then those who have ADHD and mild anxiety should go to work.
When the presenter, Nick Robinson, put it to her that it was unreasonable to use an exceptional case as a guide to what most disabled people should be doing, Badenoch did not agree. “We do use extreme examples to illustrate things,” she said.
Robinson tried again, saying she was taking “one extreme case [to] imply that anybody on disability benefits should just get on with it”. Badenoch accused him of “faux outrage” and “tone policing”. She added:
People are free to disagree, but they know where I’m coming from.
I will post more from the interview shortly.
Today the news will be dominated by two summits. This afternoon Burnham is in Berlin for a meeting of the pro-Ukraine coalition of the willing. We have coverage of this on our Europe live blog.
And in China, Vladimir Putin, who invaded Ukraine, Xi Jinping, his leading ally, and Donald Trump, who is seen by many as a closet Putin ally, are meeting now. You can read about that here.
We will have comments open in about an hour. That is because I will be doing a Q&A this afternoon, probably from about 3pm, and I will try to answer as many questions as possible. Do post them below the line.
Here is the agenda for the day.
9.30am: Louise Haigh, the first secretary of state and Cabinet Office minister, takes questions in the Commons.
10am: The Conservative party announces the results of the first round of voting in the election of its candidate for London mayor for 2028. James Cleverly, the former home secretary and former foreign secretary, is expected to get more than 50% of the vote, meaning a second round of voting should not be necessary.
11.30am: Downing Street holds a lobby briefing.
Noon: Heather Hallett, the Covid inquiry chair, publishes her report on the test, trace and isolate system.
Around 12.15pm (UK time): Andy Burnham arrives in Berlin for a meeting of the pro-Ukraine coalition of the willing. He is expected to speak to the media later in the afternoon after the plenary has finished.
1pm: Chris Bryant, the Northern Ireland secretary, attends a meeting of the British-Irish Intergovernmental Conference in Dublin.
Updated