Andrew Pulver 

A Dirty Shame review

Part of the problem is that the casting just doesn't work but mostly it's that the gags that probably made everyone laugh on the page fall thuddingly flat, one after the other, on screen
  
  

Johnny Knoxville in A Dirty Shame
Johnny Knoxville in A Dirty Shame Photograph: New Line Cinema/Allstar

For years John Waters has got by on a bucket-load of charm, more than making up for the cinematic deficiencies of his signature cocktail of high camp and bad taste. He had a great run in the 1980s and 90s, with Hairspray, Cry-Baby and Serial Mom - but, sad to say, almost all the qualities that made those movies so wonderful have deserted him in this one.

America's holier-than-thou cult of chastity is Waters' target here: Tracey Ullman plays a grumpy housewife who turns into a sex addict after being hit on the head and Johnny Knoxville (proving once again that life after Jackass is going to be very difficult) is her satanic, fire-breathing tempter. Part of Waters's problem is that the casting just doesn't work - Ullman isn't remotely engaging enough, and Knoxville is plain awful - but mostly it's that the gags that probably made everyone laugh on the page fall thuddingly flat, one after the other, on screen.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*