Over the past decade I’ve been invited into a lot of rooms: boardrooms, school halls, clinics, conference centres. I’ve even been cornered at a Sunday barbecue, where I’d wrongly assumed I was off the clock. On Wednesday, it was the National Press Club.
The brief in all these settings is the same.
How do we stop men slipping through the cracks? How do we talk to our boys before they go down the manosphere rabbit hole? Can you have a word with my husband? He won’t go to the doctor.
Strip those back and they ask one question: “What’s wrong with men?”
Of course the question usually comes from love, and the stakes are real. Men are hurting themselves – and women – in ways this country is begging us to change. The male suicide rate has fallen to its lowest rate in a decade, but three in four Australians who take their own lives are still men, and that gap has barely shifted in a generation.
The men’s health sector has learned the hard way that warnings can backfire. Tell a man “most men don’t talk”, and he doesn’t hear “you should start talking”. He hears “it’s normal not to talk”. Men are wired to belong, so we calibrate our behaviour to what we think other men do.
The trouble is, we’re often wrong. Psychologists call it “pluralistic ignorance”. Privately, many men want closer friendships, would welcome a mate asking how they’re really going, and wince at sexist banter. But each assumes he’s the odd one out, so he goes along with a norm that far fewer men hold than anyone thinks. That gap is where so much harm hides, and where so much change is waiting.
A 15-year-old in my therapy room recently laid out his dilemma. His footy coach says harden up. School says don’t be toxic. His girlfriend says be more vulnerable. His feed says lift, get rich, don’t trust women. “Who’s right?”
Our grandfathers had a rigid doctrine of how to be a man. It limited them in many ways and protected them in others, but it was clear. My own grandfather died a few months ago. His values weren’t served to him by an algorithm; they were steadfast, and they were his. Some of that is worth holding on to.
Today’s boys have more freedom than any generation before them, and less clarity. We tell them, loudly and often, what not to be. Not weak. Not violent. Not toxic. Not silent. But we’ve offered almost nothing in its place, so they go looking for someone who will. That’s the gap the manosphere has seized: selling certainty in uncertain times. Often they don’t even have to look. Their feeds find them.
Obsessing over those voices only widens the perception gap, making the loudest version of manhood look like the norm. Every story about the most rigid version of manhood is one fewer about the men quietly getting it right: fathers more present than ever, mates who check in, the dad in my practice who finally learned to tell his son “I’m proud of you” – the words he’d waited his whole life to hear.
Masculinity isn’t set in stone or written in our DNA. It’s made between us, at the dinner table, at the pub, in the office. And what’s made between us can be remade.
For 20 years, our answer to men’s health has been individual: speak up, reach out, check yourself. Women’s health has shown what’s possible when we fix the system instead of blaming the individual.
That means health services that ask new dads how they’re going: three in five in our research were never asked during their partner’s pregnancy or in their child’s first year, even though we know around one in 10 experience postnatal depression. It means clinicians trained to reach the young man whose only answer is “I don’t know”. It means sporting clubs where coaches, parents and volunteers, the entire ecosystem around a boy, know what to look for. And it means platforms held accountable for what their algorithms push to young men.
My son, Arty, is 10 months old. When I hold him, I see endless possibility. Nobody looks at a baby boy and sees a risk waiting to happen. We see potential waiting to be backed. Somewhere between the cot and the classroom, we lose that.
At the Press Club on Wednesday, I put it to the people who write the headlines, set the budgets and make the laws: tell the story of what’s possible for men, not only what’s wrong with them. Build the scaffolding. And expect more of men, because shame stifles progress and aspiration drives it.
Give men something worth growing towards and they’ll rise to meet it.
• Dr Zac Seidler is a clinical psychologist and global director of research at Movember
In Australia, the crisis support service Lifeline is 13 11 14. In the US, the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline is 1-800-273-8255. In the UK, Samaritans can be contacted on 116 123. Other international suicide helplines can be found at befrienders.org