Mike McCahill 

Stonehearst Asylum review – supremely entertaining Poe-inspired gothic thriller

This well-done riff on an Edgar Allan Poe story about blurring lines between doctors and patients puts the eccentric characters to the fore and keeps Poe’s subtleties intact
  
  

ben Kingsley in Stonehearst Asylum
A gothic Gosford Park … Ben Kingsley in Stonehearst Asylum. Photograph: Allstar/Millennium

The latest knowing genre item from director Brad Anderson (Transsiberian, The Call) has the advantage of superior source material: riffing on Edgar Allan Poe’s The System of Doctor Tarr and Professor Fether, it dispatches idealistic doc Jim Sturgess to a remote fin-de-siècle institution where the boundaries between inmates and custodians prove porous at best. Wielding a budget ample enough to bring this murderous upstairs-downstairs tumult to ghoulish life, Anderson stocks each scene with so many eccentric homegrown performers that events soon resemble a gothic Gosford Park.

The film team review Stonehearst Asylum

The character-centric approach affords everyone – from rival shrinks Ben Kingsley and Michael Caine to David Thewlis’s leering steward and Sophie Kennedy Clark’s naughty nurse – their moments of madness, while Anderson’s laudable resistance to the usual bangs and crashes preserves Poe’s subtler ironies and resonances: Dr Freud would surely have been rather taken by Sturgess’s dinky Derringer. You’ll watch this supremely entertaining danse macabre with the broadest of connoisseurial smiles.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*