Mike McCahill 

El Sur review – haunting story of a girl’s quest to understand her father

Spirit of the Beehive director Victor Erice’s 1950s-set drama is an intimate study of a girl’s attempts to fathom out – and forgive – her father
  
  

Victor Erice’s 1983 film El Sur.
Curious child … Victor Erice’s 1983 film El Sur Photograph: Publicity image

Here’s a vivid rediscovery. Ten years after 1973’s now canonical The Spirit of the Beehive, Victor Erice made this richly rewarding 1950s-set drama, which feels very much like an extension of its predecessor’s chief narrative concern – a child’s curiosity about a figure who might be a giant, a monster, or merely a man. Rather than Frankenstein’s creature, eight-year-old Estrella (Sonsoles Aranguren) is beholden to a charismatic doctor father (Omero Antonutti) who divines water between unexplained spells in seclusion. He could represent any number of patrician leaders, but Erice’s handling proves more intimate than allegorical, beckoning us into Vermeer-like compositions – and the cinema once again – while the older Estrella’s narration attempts to fathom out (and forgive) her padre, much as post-Franco Spain was reconciling itself with its own past. Another hour was planned before funding was cut, yet the ellipses only add to its hushed, haunting mystery: even in its “unfinished” state, the final movement is little short of heartbreaking.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*